This is not a comprehensive list -- these are basically my favourites (and I am an incurable bookworm with a taste for heroic heroes). I hope for suggestions and welcome input. I'm sorry there are no heroines yet. I'll try to get to them.
Obviously, this list is a little arbitrary. I am not nearly as extensively read as I should like to be. But these are, essentially, either my favourites or ones that would be if I had any sense. In an original version of this post, I included historical characters, but as this is mostly a fiction blog, I have revised some.
24. Harry Feversham (A. E. W. Mason)
However little I like the book The Four Feathers, I did very much like Harry Feversham, the coward who proves himself to his lady love. He commits great acts of bravery and has many adventures, and it isn't his fault that the plot of the book is entirely wrong. (Note: this is one occasion when the film is better than the book.)
23. Robin Hood (Various)
I never cared much for Robin Hood, but he is famous and a helper of the poor and downtrodden, thereby demonstrating some amount of greatness.
22. David Balfour (Robert Louis Stevenson)
From the great adventure story Kidnapped, David Balfour is a fine sort of hero who has many adventures and a good amount of moral fortitude. Even if he was tutored by a Campbell . . .
21. Nicholas Nickleby (Charles Dickens)
Now, if I went about putting all the great Dickens heroes on, I would have a very long list; but I have warned that I will be arbitrary. Nicholas Nickleby is a very endearing sort of person who saves abused half-wits, has an evil uncle and an innocent sister, and has to aid maidens in distress. A very excellent combination for a hero, and O! when he caned Wackford Squires the reader's heart leapt for satisfaction!
20. James Bond (Ian Fleming)
Most people like James Bond, I am told, and he does have the advantage of being the most famous spy in literature and therefore I will allow him these bragging rights. He does have good taste in automatics -- though I would have gone for the Sauer.
19. Samwise Gamgee (J. R. R. Tolkein)
I am not personally attracted to Sam; in my own opinion, Peregrin Took is a more likeable character, or Imrahil of Dol Amroth. But too many people like the son of Hamfast, and so, bowing to popular opinion, I let him stay. He is the person who forces the Ringbearer on to do his daring deed, and the one who saves him at all the many times when he can't do it himself. I fully agree that Samwise is more heroic than Frodo -- still it wasn't he who destroyed the ring (which, for all I could see, was the entire point of the story). By the laws of literature, then, Smeagol would be the hero of The Lord of the Rings -- is that uproar I hear in the distance??
18. Jeeves (P. G. Wodehouse)
You may kick to find him so high up -- I am sorry, but though Jeeves is essential, he isn't so much the heroic type. Still, he is a save-the-day-er, and he is ranked as one of the '100 Best Characters Since 1900' . Some of us may have better reasons to object to him than Piers Morgan's -- however, few can deny his eternal, impersonal charm.
17. Beowulf (Anonymous)
The famous hero of one of the oldest adventure stories in the English (so-called) language is the epic example of the monster-slayer.
16. Atticus Finch (Harper Lee)
From To Kill A Mockingbird. The heroic lawyer who charmed the world. That's all that needs to be said, isn't it?
15. Sir Gawain (Anonymous)
Famous for his fight with the Green Knight, Sir Gawain is a moral, brave, and very principled knight.
14. Fitzwilliam Darcy (Jane Austen)
I didn't want to put him this high up, but someone has to be. We all know the fantastic hero of Pride and Prejudice -- but I think I must admit that Colin Firth's spectacular portrayal of him is what really endears him to our hearts.
13. Odysseus (Homer)
The hero of The Odyssy, Odysseus, has many, if violent, adventures -- perhaps his character is lacking in some ways, but he is certainly a famous hero.
12. Prince Florizel of Bohemia (Robert Louis Stevenson)
Perhaps it is because he is a prince, or perhaps it is for more admirable reasons entirely, but this noble 'detective' (from The Rajah's Diamond and The Suicide Club) is quite an impressive hero. He startled me when we first met -- I believe he belongs on this list.
11. Horne Fisher (G. K. Chesterton)
Don't feel bad if you've never heard of him -- but the super-intelligent hero of The Man Who Knew Too Much is the best amateur detective in all of detective literature. Cool, over-informed, politically knowledgeable, and good at heart, he beats Holmes and even Father Brown without even trying.
10. Phileas Fogg (Jules Verne)
Appearing in Around the World in Eighty Days, Phileas Fogg is taciturn, very English, and fascinatingly impersonal. He is also brave, determined, and an unlikely romantic interest.
9. Rupert Psmith (P.G. Wodehouse)
I hate to relegate anyone to the 'middle-distance', as Psmith would say himself, just for the fact that no one knows who he is. Still, I feel it is my duty to do it -- although I owe a great deal to the main character of Psmith in the City et al. Perhaps we have all heard of Bertie Wooster, but it is Psmith 'the Worker', the socialistic, the verbose, and the intensely charismatic, that marks the pinnacle of Wodehouse's prowess. In the American phraseology 'Ya gotta luvim.'
8. Keith Mallory (Alistair MacLean)
Although a personal favourite, the protagonist of the magnificent thriller The Guns of Navarone is less widely known -- and certainly Gregory Peck's interpretation in the film does not do him justice. The staid and stolid New Zealander is as brave as he is responsible, as reluctant to kill as he is determined to fulfill his mission. And he is a famous mountain climber, which adds to his charm.
6. Jean Valjean (Victor Hugo)
One cannot deny either Valjean's fame or versatility -- surviving one's own funeral is rather a feat. He is also the epic example of a forgiving soul, and as adventuresome a role model as he is a compassionate. I have loved him since I met him when I was fifteen.
7, Lord Jim (Joseph Conrad)
From the book by the same title, Jim is a very gripping sort of hero; one with whom all of us can identify, and one who makes the reader pause and examine himself. In my personal opinion, he rivals Sydney Carton -- indeed, the final two pages of the book are as vividly beautiful as the last chapter of A Tale of Two Cities.The book is also amazingly written, which is part of the reason Jim is so personal and the ultimate climax so powerful.
6. Jean Valjean (Victor Hugo)
One cannot deny either Valjean's fame or versatility -- surviving one's own funeral is rather a feat. He is also the epic example of a forgiving soul, and as adventuresome a role model as he is a compassionate. I have loved him since I met him when I was fifteen.
5. Hamlet, Prince of Denmark (William Shakespeare)
I have no qualms about dismissing Hamlet to the stratosphere -- being though he is the most famous on this list, he is also the least heroic. Still, he is a hero, and a richly colourful one at that, and my first love from Shakespeare. Therefore, he appears. Besides, he fences wonderfully. And he pays for his morbid/maniacal tendencies.
4. Sir Percy Blakeney (Emuska Orczy)
A definite hero of the highest breed (and highest title), the Scarlet Pimpernel is a fabulous actor and extremely unselfish sort of baronet. Any Englishman who is willing to have the world think him a fop in order to save a few French nobles must be revered.
3. Tintin (Herge)
Say I am a fanatic. Say I am unfair. Say that he isn't literature. I defy you. Tintin is a marvelous hero: he has a small dog, he wears those funny golfing trousers, he has twice the fun of Indiana Jones and James Bond, he is only in his teens, he's a humanitarian, and he says 'Great Snakes' and 'Crumbs'. What is there not to admire?
2. Sydney Carton (Charles Dickens)
Perhaps he should be first -- I will let you argue with me. Even if he is a dissipated old souse, he certainly reforms by the end of A Tale of Two Cities, and he is a fantastic example of Dickens' intelligence.
1. Sandy Arbuthnot, Lord Clanroyden (John Buchan)
You have never heard of him? How could you not have? Actually, I am not at all surprised. Still, Sandy Arbuthnot is one of the most amazing heroes in my acquaintance. I didn't even know any heroes until I met him in Greenmantle. Somehow, his charisma, his down-to-earth Britishness, his eccentric disguises, his amazing intelligence, and his thoroughly human failings form one of the greatest heroes of all time.